First-Round Interview Checklist for HR Managers

First-round interviews are critical for identifying top candidates quickly and efficiently. Here’s what you need to know to streamline the process:

• Purpose: Evaluate basic qualifications, communication skills, and alignment with company values.
• Goals:
  • Confirm skills and experience.
  • Assess compatibility with company culture.
  • Reduce time-to-hire by up to 40%.
• Tools: AI platforms like HireVue and Interviewer AI can cut interview costs by 50% and speed up evaluations.
• Key Steps:
  • Prepare with structured scoring systems to avoid bias.
  • Use video platforms with stable setups for virtual interviews.
  • Combine AI-driven insights with human judgment for better decisions.

Outcome: A faster, fairer, and more effective first-round interview process that helps you find the right candidates while saving time and resources.

Related video from YouTube

Pre-Interview Planning

First-round interviews require careful preparation and the right tools. Many HR managers now rely on AI-powered platforms to streamline candidate screening and keep evaluations organized. Here’s a closer look at essential pre-interview steps.

AI Tools for Screening

AI platforms play a crucial role in structured scoring systems. For example, HireVue users have reported cutting their time-to-hire by 90% and interview costs by 50%. Here are some leading options:

Jonathan Fearn, Talent Acquisition Partner at Nestlé, highlights the impact of these tools:

"We’re able to learn more about people than we could ever learn from a piece of paper, and we can do it at scale and with speed"

While technology is a powerful ally, asking the right questions is equally important for effective candidate evaluation.

Key Interview Questions

Combining behavioral and situational questions offers a well-rounded view of a candidate’s abilities. Here’s how to structure your approach:

• Role-Specific Questions
  Use standardized questions to evaluate both technical know-how and interpersonal skills.
• Behavioral Assessment
  Focus on past experiences that show relevant skills. Deniz K., VP of Talent Acquisition, shares:

"The AI-generated interview questions are not only tailored to each candidate but also insightful. This feature not only saves me time but ensures that every interview I conduct is purposeful"

Assessment Guidelines

Clear evaluation criteria are essential for objective and consistent assessments. The framework below can help structure the process:

Align AI workflows with your company’s core values and hiring goals. Many organizations using this approach have reduced time-to-fill positions by up to 70%.

Running First Interviews

First-round interviews have shifted to video platforms and AI tools. A recent study shows that 86% of employers now use automated video interviews, with 74% reporting faster hiring and 79% finding the process easier to manage.

Video Platform Setup

Before starting any interview, perform a full system check. RippleMatch emphasizes:

"No matter how well you prepare for your interview, things can still go wrong. If all doesn’t go as planned, take a deep breath. Do not panic. Call your interviewer back, and if they aren’t able to pick up, send them an email explaining the situation. In most cases, hiring teams will understand and won’t hold it against you."

Develop clear guidelines to maintain a strong technical setup throughout the process.

Interview Guidelines

Consistency and professionalism are key to fair candidate evaluations. Video interviews are reported to be six times faster than phone interviews, and 92% of companies say skills-based hiring is more effective than traditional methods.

Following a structured process ensures that the speed and convenience of technology don’t compromise fairness. Valerie Vadala shares her thoughts on virtual interviews:

"Virtual interviews are the number one pandemic silver lining. No more taking half days, sneaking out for two hours for a ‘dentist appointment,’ shoving blazers in your bag to put on when you leave the building. It makes interviewing so much easier for both sides."

To maintain professionalism:

• Use consistent evaluation criteria for all candidates.
• Record sessions for team review (with the candidate’s consent).
• Leverage AI tools to analyze interview data.
• Provide immediate technical support if needed.

sbb-itb-1a6e214

Candidate Evaluation

Candidate evaluation blends AI-driven insights with human expertise to make hiring decisions based on data. AI tools help reduce hiring bias by 30% and can decrease time-to-hire by up to 75%.

Quick Assessment Process

This process integrates AI analytics with human judgment:

Christoph Hohenberger, Co-founder and Managing Director at Retorio, highlights:

"We are an assisting tool."

Rita Wittek-Verbeek, Director of People, shares this advice:

"It’s really important to block some time immediately after every interview. You can write down everything as soon as possible. That way you can actually uncover a lot about specific behaviors and competencies."

Selection Process

Once initial assessments are complete, AI scores are combined with human insights for better candidate selection. Research shows that 67% of recruiters prioritize eye contact, tone, and body language when making hiring decisions.

Rita Wittek-Verbeek adds:

"Remember, no signal = no conclusion. Don’t write something down because you think that’s what the person would have said. If it didn’t come up, then you need another interview."

To ensure accuracy, complete scorecards immediately after interviews to document observed behaviors and skills. AI tools help maintain consistency across evaluations by focusing on key abilities rather than outdated metrics.

Conclusion

Key Takeaways

First-round interviews now blend human expertise with AI-driven tools, requiring candidates and recruiters to adapt their strategies.

Here’s a breakdown of the focus areas:

"Interviewer.AI has helped us automate the screening process and make it more time efficient."

Looking Ahead: AI in Recruitment

As AI continues to shape recruitment, staying ahead means addressing emerging challenges and opportunities. Here’s what to watch for:

"The Pre-Interview Video was very valuable to give all qualified candidates an opportunity to interview and be evaluated with a lens focused on their skills, experience, and presence relevant to the position."

Success lies in balancing technology with human input. Regularly reviewing AI tools, keeping interviewers well-trained, and ensuring compliance with EEO standards are crucial. With 20% of interviewers still asking illegal questions, ongoing oversight is non-negotiable. As recruitment evolves, blending AI efficiency with human insight will remain a top priority.

Tools and References

Interview Software Options

AI-driven video interview platforms can cut hiring times by up to 40%. Below are some highly-rated platforms, along with their standout features:

When choosing a platform, keep these factors in mind:

• Integration with your ATS
• Options for branding and customized communication
• The extent of AI automation and analysis
• Availability of technical support and training

"It was immediate to me that you can save a lot of time, and get a much better understanding of candidates via virtual interviews vs. just a resume." – Phil Strazzulla, HR Tech Expert and Founder of SelectSoftware Reviews

Improving your skills alongside using the right tools can make a big difference.

Learning Materials

HR professionals can sharpen their AI recruitment expertise with these resources:

Certification Programs: The AIRS Certified AI and Sourcing Recruiter (CASR) Learning Path offers a mix of:

• Instructor-led sessions
• Self-paced modules
• Practice quizzes
• Expert-led office hours
• Professional certification

Online Learning Platforms: Platforms like LinkedIn Learning, Coursera, Udemy, and edX provide courses focused on using AI in recruitment. These cover everything from basic concepts to advanced algorithms for sourcing and screening. The combination of theory and hands-on practice ensures HR managers stay on top of emerging technologies.

Related Blog Posts

• How to Implement Video Screening in Your Hiring Process
• 5 Signs Your Candidate Screening Needs Automation
• AI Video Interviews vs. Traditional Fit Assessments